SUBORDINATION EDUCATION by Vincent Marino

The subordination provision in a lease is very important. From a tenant's standpoint, if a lease is subordinate to a deed of trust granted by the landlord, the lease is generally terminated upon a subsequent foreclosure of the deed of trust. The buyer at a foreclosure sale might, under certain circumstances, attempt to continue the lease regardless of whether it is subordinate, but if the lease is not a favorable lease (e.g., the lease provides for a rental that is substantially below-marke, or contains other unfavorable provisions), a new owner may instead elect to have the tenant vacate the property after the foreclosure, rather than continuing the lease.

Sometimes the course of action could result in a ratification of a lease. For example, a lender forecloses on property on which there is a lease executed after execution of the deed of trust. The deed of trust is clearly superior to the lease, but if the tenant, after foreclosure, continues to pay rent under the lease and the lender continues to accept such rent, there may be a good argument that the lease has been affirmed and ratified. This could be either good or bad for a particular party. For example, if a lease is deemed ratified, a new owner/landlord might be subjected to certain unwanted obligations and liabilities under the lease.

A lease can be subordinate either by way of its later date of execution (relative to the execution date of the deed of trust) or by way of agreement of the parties. For example, if a lease is executed after a deed of trust is filed, then the lease is subordinate to the deed of trust. Even if the lease is executed before the deed of trust, it may still be subordinate by way of a subordination provision contained in the lease itself or by way of a separate subordination agreement executed contemporaneously therewith or anytime thereafter.

If a lease is subordinate, a tenant could obtain some protection by requesting and receiving a subordination and non-disturbance agreement. An SNDA basically could say that, regardless of whether a foreclosure occurs, the new owner agrees to recognize the tenant as its tenant. Whether a landlord will agree to pursue an SNDA for a particular tenant depends on various factors, including the willingness of the landlord (or mortgage lender) to cooperate and the tenant's bargaining power. It is entirely possible that a landlord may not want to bother its lender for an SNDA if the tenant is leasing a small space or because the landlord does not want to incur any costs because it and the lender have previously agreed on a charge for the lender's granting SNDAs. And, of course, there may be lenders who just won't agree to execute an SNDA unless specifically required by the deed of trust.

It should be noted that, with reference to foreclosures occurring after May 20, 2009, there is a new federal statute ("Protecting Tenants at Foreclosure Act of 2009") that may allow certain bona fide "dwelling or residential real property" tenants (who are current in their lease obligations) to remain in possession for at least 90 days after a notice to vacate is given even if their lease is subordinate to the deed of trust. This new federal law, which contains various exceptions, is scheduled to sunset on December 31, 2012.

Sometimes a deed of trust will contain a provision allowing the lender to unilaterally subordinate the deed of trust to a subsequent lease. A provision of that type grants a lender some flexibility. For example, if the lender desires to foreclose and not cause a termination of a favorable lease, the lender could by separate instrument (or perhaps in the notice of the foreclosure sale and trustee's deed) unilaterally subordinate the deed of trust to the subsequent lease - with the effect of the lender's foreclosing and accepting the property "subject to" a lease. There is some risk associated with a lender taking "subject to" an existing lease. The lender may be bound by lease amendments of which the new owner has no prior notice, including, for example, amendments changing the rental or otherwise modifying other terms of the lease or requiring monetary payments to the tenant. In addition, a new owner could be liable for damages arising out of a prior landlord's conduct. Proper advance planning could reduce, eliminate or at least alert the lender of some of these risks.

- Vincent Marino is a shareholder in Winstead's Houston Office, working in the Real Estate Development & Investments practice.

Freddie and Fannie sitting in a tree, K-I-S-S-I-N-G!

Last week, my brother sent me a link to a Yahoo.com news story that announced what several of my clients have been predicting:  "Homes being dumped on the market at the end of 2010; beginning of 2011 so as to allow the banks to liquidate their REO inventory quickly."

I, myself, have resisted going after residential homes/condos for fear that when this does happen, I don't want to be the sucker that purchased a property far above the "dumping" price.

Here is the link so you can see for yourself:
http://financiallyfit.yahoo.com/finance/article-110858-6830-2-tips-on-buying-a-home----at-a-100000-discount?ywaad=ad0035&nc 

Now, I am all for Banks getting back to lending.  They seemed to have taken the "Stimulus Money" and ran with it.  As we all know, they are NOT lending -- which was my understanding they were supposed to do.  But, maybe with the banks (specifically FreddieMac and Fannie Mae) unloading the thousands of homes/condos that are filling their inventory at $100,000 less than the foreclosed price, will help jump start the bottom of the housing sales crisis.

As a fellow American, I expect, as you do, instant gratification.  This recession/depression should have been over a long time ago.  Whether your slant is to to blame Republicans or Democrats, neither has done enough to satisfy us instant gratification Americans.

But, unless American workers get back to work, there will NOT be the magnificient recovery we are all anticipating.  Corporate America doesn't want to pay Americans a living wage, foregn countires are underpaying employees so as to undercut the American dream, and American workers who won't work for less are the losers.  By the way, if Americans can NOT earn a living wage, they can NOT buy homes! (FYI.)

So, even dumping these REO properties, who -- other than investors -- can buy a home if the American Buyer doesn't have a good paying job; can't get a loan because the banks have put the brakes on lending, and, essentially, don't qualify because they let their last over-paid for house go back to the bank?

And, unless this cycle is brought to an end, home prices will continue to decline -- even with the "dumping."

Oh!  And with this continued decline in value, commercial real estate will decline in value because right here in Las Vegas, there is so much vacancy in office, industrial and retail, that they can't even give the space away for free -- even if they thought that would improve their properties financial outlook.

For Information about Las Vegas Commercial Real Estate, RE Investments, or Commercial Property, contact David Howes at: david@davidhowes.net